When renovating a bathroom, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to install a walk-in shower or a bath. Both have their advantages and drawbacks, and the best choice depends on your space, lifestyle, and personal preferences. To help you decide, we’ve broken down the key factors to consider.

The Case for Walk-In Showers

Walk-in showers have become increasingly popular in modern bathrooms, offering a sleek and contemporary look. They are especially well-suited to homes where accessibility is a priority.

Pros of Walk-In Showers

✅ Space-Saving & Open Feel – Walk-in showers can make a bathroom feel larger and more open, especially when using frameless glass panels. However, some modern designs with large shower trays or enclosures may take up as much space as a bath.

✅ Easy Accessibility – Ideal for individuals with mobility issues, as there’s no need to step over a tub edge.

✅ Low Maintenance – Without a tub to clean, maintenance is generally easier and quicker.

✅ Water Efficiency – Showers typically use less water than filling a bath, especially with an eco-friendly showerhead.

✅ Modern Aesthetic – Sleek, minimalist, and stylish, a walk-in shower can add a high-end feel to any bathroom.

Cons of Walk-In Showers

❌ No Bathing Option – If you enjoy soaking in a tub, a walk-in shower won’t provide the same relaxation.

❌ Potential Splashing – Without a full enclosure, walk-in showers can sometimes allow water to escape onto the bathroom floor.

❌ Reduced Home Value in Some Cases – If you remove the only bath in your home, it may affect resale appeal for families with young children

The Case for Baths

For many homeowners, a bath is synonymous with relaxation and comfort. It offers a traditional approach to bathing while also serving as a practical choice for families with young children.

Pros of Baths

✅ Great for Relaxation – Nothing beats a long soak in the tub for unwinding after a stressful day.

✅ Ideal for Families – Bathing small children is much easier in a tub than in a shower.

✅ Adds Value to Your Home – Homes with at least one bath tend to have broader market appeal.

✅ Versatile Options – Freestanding, built-in, or whirlpool tubs offer different styles to match your bathroom’s design.

Cons of Baths

❌ Takes Up More Space – A standard bathtub requires significant room, which may not be ideal for smaller bathrooms.

❌ Higher Water Usage – A full bath uses significantly more water than a quick shower, which may lead to higher utility bills.

❌ More Cleaning Required – A bath may require more effort to keep clean, especially if used frequently or if it has jets or textured surfaces that can collect grime over time

Cost Comparison: Walk-In Shower vs. Bath

Which One Is Right for You?

Choose a Walk-In Shower If:

• You have a smaller bathroom and need to maximise space.

• You prefer a modern, open-plan design.

• Accessibility and ease of use are top priorities.

• You want a low-maintenance option.

Choose a Bath If:

• You enjoy long soaks and a spa-like experience.

• You have young children who need a tub for bathing.

• You want to maintain or increase your home’s resale value.

• You have the space to accommodate a bathtub comfortably.

Can You Have Both a Shower and a Bath?

Absolutely — if the space is right. Plenty of homeowners in Exeter and beyond dream of having both a walk-in shower and a bath, and when the room allows, it’s a brilliant way to enjoy the best of both worlds.

In larger bathrooms, we often see stunning layouts with a freestanding bath alongside a generous shower enclosure, creating a spa-like feel that’s as practical as it is luxurious. It gives you flexibility too — a quick rinse before work or a long soak on a Sunday afternoon.

Some go even further with a wet room design, where a freestanding bath and open shower area share one waterproofed, seamless space. Done right, it’s modern, functional, and absolutely striking.

But here’s the thing: we’ve also seen the flipside. People trying to cram both into a space that just can’t quite handle it. The result? A cramped layout that’s awkward to use and hard to maintain — not to mention potentially putting strain on your plumbing setup.

Our advice? Think practically. If you’re unsure, get a professional opinion early. At EPM, we can help assess whether your bathroom has the space to do both well — and if not, help you choose the best layout to suit your needs and lifestyle.

Done properly, a combined setup can definitely add to your home’s comfort, appeal, and even resale value. But it’s got to be the right fit for the space — and for you.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the choice between a walk-in shower and a bath comes down to your personal needs, lifestyle, and available space. Both options offer distinct benefits, and selecting the right one will enhance your bathroom’s functionality and aesthetic appeal.

If you’re still unsure, our team at EPM can help you design the perfect bathroom setup that suits your home and budget. Contact us today for expert advice!